IT EN
Header background

A turning point for consulting

by Antonello Di Mascio, Chief Research Officer of Gruppo Excellence, for Private magazine

The debate over AI versus advisers remains intense and seems to echo the debate between robo and human asset managers of a few years ago. Certainly, the generational shift in the client base and the intergenerational transfer of wealth will play a significant role in how AI and advisers coexist.

Operational wealth strategies
Over the next ten years, the adviser will remain the cornerstone for building client loyalty, retention and a service model capable of managing the changes taking place in the banking sector. This article analyses how artificial intelligence is supporting, rather than replacing, this central figure across four dimensions: assistant, trainer, salesperson and expert. Behavioural economist Shlomo Benartzi, in an opinion piece in The Wall Street Journal (cited by Emanuela Notari in “A sigh of relief for advisers: here is why AI will not win”, Investire Specialist, November 2023), debunked the myth of the replacement of human advisers, identifying the hybrid model already proven in medicine as the trajectory for wealth management. The most mature case, according to an account published by OpenAI (“Morgan Stanley uses AI evals to shape the future of financial services”, 2024), is Morgan Stanley, whose AI assistant queries various proprietary research documents, increasing the proportion of documentation accessible to an adviser from 20% to 80%.

We can regard the evolution of next-best-action—the automatic recommendation of the most appropriate action to take with a client—as the operational and commercial priority for the coming years: algorithms of this kind already exist today, but AI will be able to turn NBA into a dynamic recommendation that takes account, in real time, of market conditions, the client’s spending over the previous three months and inflows over a given period. AI will therefore be able to generate an NBA by analysing external information and contextualising it with internal information. Of particular interest is the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) study “Generative AI at Work”, Working Paper 31161, October 2023, which measured a 14% increase in problems resolved per hour of work thanks to generative tools, with greater benefits for less experienced workers. Indeed, there are two ends of the spectrum: with AI support, more experienced advisers can increase their productivity in developing proposals and conducting analysis, while less experienced advisers increase their productivity by reducing document processing and learning times.

Behavioural profiling
Mary Callahan Erdoes’s letter to shareholders in JPMorganChase’s 2025 Annual Report states that, through AI-guided exercises, the bank recorded a 150% increase in practice simulations and a 27% reduction in cost per adviser trained. In the Italian market, however, the OECD and Bank of Italy report (2026), “Artificial intelligence in Italian financial markets”, shows a landscape that is still at an early stage: only 14% of firms have provided advanced training. Training in general will benefit from the development of AI, both in terms of technical content and, above all, through practice and simulations covering multiple aspects. AI should be conceived as an active, proactive trainer that can help professionals consolidate their strengths and, above all, overcome their weaknesses: client clustering and behavioural profiling supplied to AI can give rise to meeting simulators for different market conditions, thereby helping advisers manage clients’ emotions, fears, criticisms, comments and requests. Already today, with participants’ prior consent, we use AI in meetings to listen to and record discussions and then process them. The presence of AI is very useful in client meetings. AI drafts follow-ups but, above all, can connect what it has heard with what the bank offers, helping to formulate appropriate commercial proposals. At the same time, by listening to the meeting, it is possible to analyse clients’ questions or concerns about specific topics, cluster them and prepare personalised podcasts for the specific target group of clients. AI’s experience in the world of investments and portfolios is a natural and substantial evolution of the experience of high-frequency trading, robo-investing and robo-for-adviser tools. In this area, AI facilitates the integration of analysis of the client’s actual portfolio, the model portfolio and the optimal portfolio with the external reference scenario and event simulations. Advisers can certainly benefit from using AI to refine investment and allocation proposals, drawing on the strengths of managed investment products as well as an allocation to ETFs.

The expected benefits
Dialogue between clients and advisers will be able to benefit from AI support: according to the Nitrogen 2025 Firm Growth Survey, 78% of investors consider it important for their adviser to use modern technological tools. According to the Natixis Investment Managers 2026 Financial Adviser’s Survey (CoreData Research), 76% of advisers believe that AI still has a long way to go, and 71% have already integrated it into their daily work; while today 78% of US advisers see other professionals as their main competition, over the next five years 35%–43% instead identify AI-powered do-it-yourself tools as the more serious challenge. As Chairman Mauro Maria Marino’s remarks in the OCF Report for 2025 (Rome, 7 July 2026) remind us, innovation must remain transparent, controllable and geared towards protecting the client’s interests: the most sustainable model therefore remains the hybrid one, combining the human touch with AI-powered capabilities, in which technology frees up time to reinvest in the human relationship. We are on an evolutionary path that will continue to accelerate, and it is good to be aware of this. This awareness will help in managing flows, knowing that clients too will use artificial intelligence to check the proposals they receive.

Read all our contents